Good Review in Grey Citadel Forum

RSS
Email

0 Points

Forum Jump

Good Review

Author	Comment
DSFRIII	Good Review	Lead	[-]
Posts: 2877 Apr 15 03 8:21 AM Lich Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Tags : None Here is a nice review of Grey Citadel: www.d20zines.com/html/mod...=0&thold=0
	Remove this ad
tmcdon	review	#1	[-]
Posts: 4263 Apr 15 03 10:06 AM Type II Demon Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	That was a solid review. The "flaws" he mentioned really amount to very little and would most likely not even be noticed to someone not going over it with a fine tooth comb. I couldn't agree with the premise of his critique more. The best thing about Grey Citadel is its mix of adventure styles and the flexibility it allows the DM. Good review!
MacPhail	Re: review	#2	[-]
Posts: 2234 Apr 15 03 11:09 AM Necromantic Writer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Very cool... The level of detail shows that Mr. Dean read the module thoroughly and checked out the web support as well. I have several more copies floating around out there for review... let's hope for some more like this! MacPhail Dark Loch Creative Enterprises
Justrollindice	Re: review	#3	[-]
Posts: 13 Apr 16 03 11:03 AM Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Great review. Got this adventure recently and it rocks! Didn't expect it to be for 5th levels, though. Thought it was going to be higher.
MacPhail	Re: review	#4	[-]
Posts: 2234 Apr 16 03 11:38 AM Necromantic Writer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	I'm glad you like it! As for power level, the timed city encounters consist primarily of encounters of multiple opponents... just add in extra creatures/enemies (possibly even doubling them) and you should be fine. Just watch out for heroes with the Cleave feat. For the rest of the encounters, adding extra small creatures works well, and adding levels or hit dice to the big ones is a bit more involved, but worth doing. In general, a higher-level party should still find the adventure challenging. However, they will be able to go further and accomplish more without depleting hit points and spells, so they will need fewer trips back to the city to recuperate. Let us know how it goes! MacPhail
tmcdon	Hey Mac	#5	[-]
Posts: 4263 Apr 16 03 6:28 PM Type II Demon Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Hey Mac, Did I tell you that you did a really great job on this Module? I'm on the second read through and doing the little tweaks to level it up. My group should go through it here in about 3 weeks.
	Remove this ad
MacPhail	Re: Hey Mac	#6	[-]
Posts: 2234 Apr 16 03 6:54 PM Necromantic Writer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	You have, actually, but I'll let you know when I get tired of hearing it... Seriously, it's nice to hear, but even better will be the tales from the game table... the thought of my ideas bringing entertainment and enjoyment to other people through something as simple as words on a page is extremely satisfying. That's probably why I keep turning out free gimmicks... I'm trying to entice people to stick around long enough to tell me what happens in their game! Thanks, Tim... I dig your enthusiasm, and I hope you'll let me know if there's anything I can do to help out. If you are levelling up the adventure, you might get some mileage out of the NPCs I just posted last night... lemme know what you think. MacPhail
Pale Writer	Re: Hey Mac	#7	[-]
Posts: 7469 Apr 17 03 1:06 AM Scribe of the Apocalypse Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	You know what was missing from this module, Mac? . . . . . . . Crampon kick damage. C'mon, man, yer slackin' here! "And so he says, 'I don't like the cut of your jib.' And I go, I says, IT'S THE ONLY JIB I GOT, BABY!"
MacPhail	Re: Hey Mac	#8	[-]
Posts: 2234 Apr 17 03 5:49 AM Necromantic Writer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Aaargh, that thing has completely stalled! I ran out of steam figuring out how to handle high altitude pulmonary embolisms. Trust me, crampon damage WILL be in there, as well as icicle damage, stabbing-somebody-with-a-piton damage and running-over-someone-while-sliding-down-a-mountain-on-your-shield damage! I decided to make it Modern-compatible, which is taking some time. I'm also trying to coax some more work out of Creek, since he's the only one of my artists who has used the gear I'm asking him to draw, but he's putting the finishing touches on his second year animation project (featuring the voice of Lee Ermey, no less). The mountaineering PDF is planned as the first non-Eamonvale release for Dark Loch, and you'll probably see it this summer. Thanks for keeping me on it! MacPhail
Tsathogga	Re: Hey Mac	#9	[-]
Posts: 2491 Apr 22 03 8:12 AM Demon Lord Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	It kinda reminded me of the A (Slaver's) series for some reason...that's why I picked Mac up...
	Remove this ad

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Good Review

Good Review