Yuku free message boards

Oh, just thought of this, as far as maps go

A really good couple of options for city maps.
1. Cities of Harn
2. The city maps for Kalamar

Both of these products have a large assortment of what any of us would happily consider a city sized settlement.

They also have all sorts of layouts, from multi river filled cities by the sea to mountain lodged cities in a travel pass.

I don't think I've found a city in either of them that I'm unhappy with.

At least from a standpoint of map design and layout.

Another thing on population.

Given the setting, and the need for city walls, I think that there's an unspoken understanding that the population numbers have got to be wrong for some of the other cities out there. Given constant wall maintenance, guard duty, city watch, governance duties, you'd have to have at least 100 or 200 people to staff a city, and then you have any standing army (since these are citystates and there's no actual nations with a national army, each city is responsible for fielding at least a command core and a force of at least militia) or militia. Then you need to triple that number to account for farmers to produce enough food for themselves AND those people that aren't producing food, clothing, or other essentials (specifically the staff needed to run the city) so at a bare minimum, 200 staff, a ruler, his minions, plus standing army as a sum, times 4 (the original people plus the 3 times as many producers to support them) starts yielding a minimum number of people needed to people an actual city.

Mind you, I'm including the farmers and such because let's be honest, given the hostile terrain and monster populations (also another reason for a standing armed force in a city) farmers are going to stay as close to the city as possible. So areas around the city will be heavily developed in terms of farms and cottage industry.

So a city minimum pop of actual people would need to be 1200 or more, add nobles and you're requiring a whole nother strata and lots more people.

The thing is, most people forget solid logistics in their campaign world. But it's just like a business, for every non producer (people that don't actually produce product) you need 2 to 3 producers just to break even in most cases. To actually turn a surplus, you need more people that actually produce tangibles.

If you add a metal industry, you need miners, smelters, etc and to produce the fuel to do the smelting, more miners (coal) or woodsmen to cut down trees and chop them up, as well as carters, engineers, etc etc etc

Add in a money standard, you need temples (banks of the period) money changers, a mint, assayers.

You know, this could actually be a good supplement for Wilderlands.

Wilderlands cities, or how to make a fantasy city that actually works.

Create a series of city sizes with tech levels for each, and include lists of how many people, and of what professions you'd need to support a city properly.

Wanna build a Bronze age tech level metropolis? How many wool merchants are there in town? How many weavers are there? How many farmers living on the outskirts? Looking to sell some jewelry from your latest foray into a forgotten tomb? How big would the city have to be to support a goldsmith, a gem cutter, and a store that sells such things and might buy your treasure, and how many are there in town in competition (to provide some competition so you can get a better price).

I smell the opportunity for a pretty good product sup there.